Open Shelving vs. Cabinets: Which One Wins the Kitchen Storage Game?

Have you ever stood in your kitchen, staring at those cabinets, and thought, “There has to be a better way to store all this stuff”? You’re not alone! Regarding kitchen storage, we’re diving into one of the biggest kitchen debates: open shelving vs. cabinets. Should you go for the chic, airy look of open shelves, or stick with the tried-and-true, hidden magic of cabinets? Both have their perks, but which one is right for you?

*This post contains affiliate links and commission may be earned*

1. Open Shelving: Show Off Your Style and Keep It Light

If you’re all about style and accessibility, open shelving might be your best friend. Open shelves create a light, airy feel in your kitchen, giving it a more spacious vibe. Plus, they let you showcase your favorite dishes, quirky mugs, or even some cute plants. And for those of us who need to see everything at once (a.k.a. avoiding the dreaded “where’s my favorite plate?” moment), open shelving makes life easier.

But remember, with open shelves, you’re committing to keeping things tidy and aesthetically pleasing. It’s not the place for your mismatched Tupperware collection or cluttered spice rack—unless you’re a pro at organizing chaos!

2. Cabinets: The Classic Clutter Hiders

Ah, cabinets. The OGs of kitchen storage. Cabinets are perfect for when you need to hide the mess. Let’s be real: not everything in your kitchen is Pinterest-ready, and that’s totally fine! Cabinets keep everything organized and out of sight, whether it’s your collection of random plastic containers, an army of spices, or that blender you only use twice a year.

Cabinets are also great for keeping things dust-free. Unlike open shelves that need regular dusting (ugh), cabinets protect your items, especially those you don’t use often. So, if you’re more of a “tuck it away” kind of person, cabinets might be the way to go.

3. Why Not Both? Mixing Open Shelving and Cabinets

Struggling to choose between open shelving and cabinets? Here’s a tip: you don’t have to pick just one! A popular trend in kitchen design is blending both elements for a perfectly balanced space. Cabinets are great for stashing away those not-so-pretty essentials (hello, food processor), while open shelves allow you to showcase your favorite items. This combo not only adds visual interest but also prevents your kitchen from looking too cluttered or too plain.

4. The Practical Stuff: What’s Right for You?

Now that we’ve looked at the aesthetic side, let’s talk practicality. When choosing between open shelving and cabinets, it’s important to consider a few things:

  • Maintenance: Open shelves look gorgeous, but they do require some upkeep. If you’re not into regular dusting or organizing, cabinets might be your safer bet.
  • Space: If you’re working with a smaller kitchen, open shelves can help make the room feel bigger and more open. But if you need maximum storage, cabinets are better for utilizing every inch of space.
  • Your Style: Are you a minimalist who likes a clean, clutter-free vibe? Cabinets will be your best friend. But if you love showcasing your personality and design flair, open shelving lets you do just that.

5. Styling Your Open Shelves Like a Pro

If you’re leaning toward open shelving, here’s a little tip to make them look super stylish: create a balance between function and decor. Don’t overstuff the shelves—less is more! Mix practical items like dishes with decorative pieces like plants, cookbooks, or some quirky kitchen art. Group items by color or texture to keep things visually cohesive, and don’t be afraid to leave a little empty space to avoid clutter.

6. Creative Cabinet Ideas: Maximize Your Hidden Space

For those who prefer cabinets, there are plenty of ways to make them more efficient and stylish. Consider pull-out shelves or lazy Susans to make deep cabinets easier to access. Add interior cabinet lighting to make everything visible and accessible, and opt for handleless cabinets for a super sleek, minimalist look. You can also play with contrasting cabinet colors for a bold design statement—white uppers and dark lower cabinets are always a winner!

7. Final Thoughts: Which is Right for You?

At the end of the day, the choice between open shelving and cabinets comes down to your personal style and how you use your kitchen. Open shelves are fantastic for showcasing your design personality and making the space feel light and open, while cabinets are perfect for keeping everything neat, tidy, and out of sight. And if you can’t decide, mixing the two is a great option for creating a balanced and functional space. The real winner? You, with a kitchen that works perfectly for your needs!

So, which team are you on? Open shelving, cabinets, or a little of both? Here are 12 example ideas

Vibrant Tropical Open Shelving

Open shelving in bright, tropical colors can bring an energetic, island-inspired vibe to your kitchen. Think bold hues like teal, coral, and sunshine yellow to make your space feel lively and cheerful.

Sleek and Minimalist Open Shelving

Open shelving is ideal for creating a light, airy, and modern feel in your kitchen. Without bulky cabinet doors, your kitchen feels more spacious. It also gives you a chance to display your best dishware and decorative pieces.

Color-Blocked Cabinets for a Playful Look

Combine open shelving and cabinets using color-blocking techniques to create a playful, modern kitchen. Mix and match bold shades like cobalt blue, emerald green, and mustard yellow for a unique, artistic flair.

Traditional Cabinets with a Pop of Color

If you love the idea of hidden storage but still want your cabinets to make a design statement, adding a pop of color to traditional cabinets can give your kitchen a bold, modern twist. Cabinets in bright or bold hues, like navy or forest green, add character without overwhelming the room.

Mixed Shelving and Cabinets for the Best of Both Worlds

Can’t decide between open shelving and cabinets? Combine both for functionality and style. Use cabinets to hide clutter and open shelves for easy access to daily essentials or decorative items.

Pastel Open Shelving for a Soft, Modern Look

For a more subtle approach to a colorful kitchen, pastel open shelving adds a soft, modern vibe. Light shades of mint green, blush pink, and powder blue create a dreamy, relaxed atmosphere while still offering visual interest.

Rustic Open Shelving for a Farmhouse Look

Open shelving can enhance the charm of a farmhouse kitchen with its rustic and inviting feel. Use reclaimed wood shelves paired with vintage-inspired accents to complete the look.

Glass-Front Cabinets for a Modern Twist

Glass-front cabinets offer the closed storage of traditional cabinetry but with the modern twist of transparency, allowing you to display beautiful dishware while keeping things tidy.

Bold and Colorful Open Shelves

Open shelving doesn’t have to blend into the background—paint your shelves in a bold color to add a playful and vibrant element to your kitchen design.

Classic All-White Cabinets for a Timeless Look

All-white cabinets create a clean, timeless look in the kitchen, making the space feel bright and expansive. Perfect for those who prefer a more classic, elegant style.

Floating Shelves in a Small Kitchen

In a small kitchen, open shelving can create the illusion of more space while offering practical storage. Floating shelves make the room feel less enclosed and provide easy access to everyday items.

Industrial-Style Open Shelving

Open shelving can enhance an industrial-style kitchen with its raw, unfinished look. Pair metal shelving units with exposed brick and steel appliances to complete the urban, industrial feel.

RELATED